Animal Welfare
Why animal welfare is central to wool sourcing
Animal welfare is no longer a niche concern: it is central to responsible sourcing, brand credibility and consumer trust. For many brands, the question customers ask most is whether their wool is free from mulesing. But welfare covers the entire lifecycle of a wool-producing sheep, from lambing to end of life, and the most critical risks along the way include mulesing, tail docking and castration, shearing injuries, nutrition, shade and shelter, chemical exposure, transport and slaughter. Those risks sit on the farm and in the shearing shed, while most brands can trace their wool no further back than the spinner.
Mulesing, which some organisations now call live lamb cutting, was originally developed to prevent flystrike in Australian sheep, but it is a painful procedure. Australia supplies around 70% of the world’s apparel wool, and an estimated three-quarters of it still comes from mulesed sheep, reportedly without pain relief at the moment it is done. Alternatives exist: breeding sheep with less wrinkled skin, strategic use of insect growth regulators, and better pasture and feed management, though a farm that stops mulesing should not simply switch to chemicals, which carry risks of their own. In New Zealand, where about half of merino farms once mulesed, growers supplying one large broker stopped within about three years, and the practice was banned by law in 2018. South Africa prohibits it too.
Standards such as RWS, ZQ Merino, NATIVA, GOTS and SPCA Certified offer important frameworks, but they cover different things, and no standard is perfect. FOUR PAWS, an animal welfare organisation, benchmarks the wool standards in its Certification Insights Report, on how each is built and on issues such as pain relief, cameras in shearing sheds and sheep dipping. Brands are encouraged to do their due diligence, understand the context in which a standard is applied, and wherever possible visit the farm.
Increasingly, brands set their position down in an animal welfare policy: a guiding philosophy, a clear stance on painful procedures, the certifications and materials they accept, an assessment of where their supply chain is exposed, and time-bound goals for improving it. A policy only works if it is implemented: suppliers are checked against it, progress is reported, and the text is revised as practice moves on.
Key takeaways for brands
- Look beyond mulesing. Ask how your wool’s standards and suppliers handle tail docking, castration, shearing, shade and shelter, nutrition, chemical use and the end of an animal’s life.
- Check whether pain relief is required for tail docking and castration, not only allowed, where it is available. Mandatory pain relief is still not common across standards, so a brand that wants it can require it in its own policy.
- Understand what each standard actually covers before relying on it. Standards differ, and none covers everything, such as what happens to sheep after their productive life.
- Ask how shearing is managed: how shearers are paid, trained and certified, whether each sheep can be traced to its shearer, and how the shed is checked. Where mulesing is banned, shearing is the biggest remaining risk.
- Visit the farm, or build direct relationships with growers, where you can. It builds trust, and the stories brands can tell. Longer contracts with a consistent group of growers also give them the confidence to invest beyond a standard’s minimum.
- Write your position down as an animal welfare policy, and give it an owner. Words a supplier signs change nothing on the farm unless someone checks, reports and revises.
All summaries were generated by an LLM directly from the transcripts of Good Wool Collective sessions. Good Wool Collective advises double checking the information presented, as in our experience expert sources can contradict each other, and the facts can change over time.
Animal Welfare Policy PlaybookGuide · PDF
Topical questions
What are flystrike and mulesing?
How can farms stop mulesing?
How is tail docking different from mulesing?
Can shearing be done better?
What happens to sheep at the end of their productive life?
What are the Five Freedoms and the Five Domains?
How can a brand assess a welfare standard?
How is a farm group of hundreds of farms actually checked?
Do certified farms earn more?
What should an animal welfare policy contain?
Does a welfare policy work if we cannot trace our wool to the farm?
Does it matter where the wool comes from?
Watch Related Sessions
Session · 5 November 2026
Writing an Ambitious Animal Welfare Policy
This session takes a deeper look at animal welfare in the wool supply chain, with a focus on what a brand’s animal welfare policy should contain when the risks sit on the farm and in the shearing shed, while most brands can trace their wool only as far as the spinner. Our expert panel discusses the biggest welfare risks by region, how large certified farm groups are audited, how one farm group responded to allegations on certified farms, and how certifications compare on animal welfare.


